The San Francisco Chronicle
SAN FRANCISCO — Two of the three pillars of CPR — opening a distressed person's airway and providing mouth-to-mouth breathing — turn out to be not so essential when it comes to saving the life of someone in cardiac arrest.
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation should begin with forceful chest compressions to keep the blood circulating through the body, according to new guidelines released today by the American Heart Association. And people who haven't been trained in CPR need not bother with providing air-passage clearance and mouth-to-mouth breathing at all, the group said.
For the first time in decades, the heart association is shaking up its ABC system: airway, breathing and circulation. Until now, it involved opening the victim's airway first, starting mouth-to-mouth breathing and doing chest compressions last.
Several large studies in the past five years, however, have found that skipping the first two steps and going straight to chest compressions yields better survival rates for people who suffer cardiac arrest. Meanwhile, by discouraging the average citizen from giving mouth-to-mouth emergency treatment, public health experts hope that more people will be willing to provide CPR to strangers.
"This is a major change. If we can just get people to start the compressions, then we can look at saving a lot more lives," said Dr. Gordon Fung, director of cardiac services at UCSF Medical Center and a board member of the San Francisco chapter of the American Heart Association.
The heart association has taught CPR to the public using the ABC system since the 1960s. Sudden cardiac arrest is a common cause of death in the United States, and only about 6 percent of victims whose hearts stop outside of a hospital survive. But CPR may as much as double the chances of survival, studies have shown.
Reluctant bystanders
Two years ago, the heart association began encouraging untrained bystanders to forego mouth-to-mouth and give chest compressions when someone collapses. Multiple studies had shown that any CPR was better than none at all, but lay people were reluctant to step in and help — perhaps in large part because they didn't want to provide mouth-to-mouth breathing.
"But the message is that you don't need to do mouth-to-mouth," said Dr. Ed Kersh, chief of cardiology at California Pacific Medical Center's St. Luke's campus. "The key is getting the circulation going again."
The only time mouth-to-mouth breathing may be necessary is in obvious cases where a person is in respiratory distress — when someone has clearly stopped breathing from drowning, for example, or from a drug overdose.
But because the vast majority of cases where a person collapses and stops breathing are due to cardiac arrest, public health experts say starting chest compressions should almost always be the priority.
In the most recent CPR study, which looked at 4,400 cardiac arrest patients and was published last week in the Journal of the American Heart Association, 13 percent of victims who got CPR using chest compressions alone survived and were eventually discharged from a hospital.
But only 7.8 percent of those who got traditional CPR with rescue breathing were discharged, which wasn't much better than the 5.2 percent of people who received no CPR at all and eventually left the hospital.
The thinking is that rescuers who use traditional CPR waste valuable time — as much as half a minute — adjusting the head to set up an airway and then providing a breath or two before starting chest compressions.
Get the blood moving
The body probably already has enough oxygen in it when a person collapses, meaning breathing usually isn't the immediate concern. What's important is getting the blood moving again and supplying vital organs with oxygen until help arrives in the form of a defibrillator, which can be used to get the heart beating on its own again.
"You're looking to push oxygenated blood to the brain and to the heart," said Dr. George Bulloch, chief of the Kaiser Permanente Redwood City emergency department. "There is enough oxygen intrinsically built in that you can concentrate on just circulating it. You're just trying to buy time until EMS can get there and supply a shock."
The new heart association guidelines also recommend more aggressive chest compressions, including faster and deeper pushes on the sternum. Rescuers should do chest compressions at a rate of 100 per minute, and push a good 2 inches down.
If the rescuer is trained in CPR, he or she may still give mouth-to-mouth assistance, at a rate of two breaths after 30 chest compressions.
One of the other advantages of recommending chest compressions only for most bystanders is that it's easy for a 911 operator to talk someone through the simpler form of CPR.
"If you call 911 and they say bend down and push, that's a quick trick," Bulloch said. "It will be eminently easier to teach."
The new CPR Here are the American Heart Association's new guidelines for cardiopulmonary resuscitation: Before starting, shake the victim's shoulders and shout to see if he responds. If the victim is not breathing, yell for someone to call 911. If you're alone, call 911. Begin chest compressions. Push hard and fast on the center of the chest at a rate of at least 100 compressions a minute which happens to be the beat of the 1977 Bee Gees disco hit "Stayin' Alive". Push down on the chest at least 2 inches with each compression. Make sure you fully release the chest before beginning the next compression. If you have not been trained in CPR, continue chest compressions until help arrives. If you have been trained, after 30 chest compressions open an airway and begin mouth-to-mouth breathing. Give two breaths, then resume chest compressions. Continue sets of 30 chest compressions and two breaths until help arrives.
"This is a major change. If we can just get people to start the compressions, then we can look at saving a lot more lives."
2010 CPR Guidelines
By Rod Brouhard, About.com Guide
Updated October 18, 2010
After a review of the available research published over a 5 year period, the American Heart Association released its 2010 CPR Guidelines. As expected, the focus for CPR is on good quality chest compressions. Here are the differences between the 2005 and the 2010 CPR Guidelines:
- A-B-C is for babies; now it's C-A-B!
It used to be follow your ABC's: airway, breathing and chest compressions. Now, Compressions come first, only then do you focus on Airway and Breathing. The only exception to the rule will be newborn babies, but everyone else -- whether it's infant CPR, child CPR or adult CPR -- will get chest compressions before you worry about the airway.
- No more looking, listening and feeling.
The key to saving a cardiac arrest victim is action, not assessment. Call 911 the moment you realize the victim won't wake up and doesn't seem to be breathing right.
Trust your gut. If you have to hold your cheek over the victim's mouth and carefully try to detect a puff of air, it's a pretty good bet she's not breathing very well, if at all.
I have a secret to share: paramedics have been doing it this way for years. Rarely have I seen an EMT or a paramedic put her ear to a victim's nose and listen for air movement. We just get to work.
- Push a little harder. How deep you should push on the chest has changed for adult CPR. It was 1 1/2 to 2 inches, but now the Heart Association wants you to push at least 2 inches deep on the chest.
- Push a little faster. AHA changed the wording here, too. Instead of pushing on the chest at about 100 compressions per minute, AHA wants you to push at least 100 compressions per minute. At that rate, 30 compressions should take you 18 seconds.
Besides the changes under the 2010 CPR Guidelines, AHA continues to emphasize some important points:
- Hands Only CPR. This is technically a change from the 2005 Guidelines, but AHA endorsed this form of CPR in 2008. The Heart Association still wants untrained lay rescuers to do Hands Only CPR on adult victims who collapse in front of them. My biggest problem with this campaign is what's left unsaid. What does AHA want untrained lay rescuers to do with all the other victims? In other words, what do you do with the victims that aren't adults or that didn't collapse right in front of you? AHA doesn't provide an answer, but I have a suggestion: Do Hands Only CPR, because doing something is always better than doing nothing.
- Recognize sudden cardiac arrest. CPR is the only treatment for sudden cardiac arrest and AHA wants you to notice when it happens.
- Don't stop pushing. Every interruption in chest compressions interrupts blood flow to the brain, which leads to brain death if the blood flow stops too long. It takes several chest compressions to get blood moving again. AHA wants you to keep pushing as long as you can. Push until the AED is in place and ready to analyze the heart. When it is time to do mouth to mouth, do it quick and get right back on the chest.